FYI: Science Policy News
FYI
/
Article

New Commission to Assess NSF Grant Review Criteria

FEB 20, 2023
Mitch Ambrose headshot
Director of Science Policy News ,  AIP
nsf-nsb-image.jpg

Logos of the National Science Foundation and National Science Board

(NSB)

The National Science Board voted unanimously last week to form a commission that will assess the intellectual merit and broader impacts criteria the National Science Foundation uses when reviewing grant applications and will report back by May 2024 with any recommended changes.

The commission is charged with evaluating the effectiveness of the current review process in “supporting NSF’s mission to create new knowledge, fully empower diverse talent to participate in STEM, and benefit society by translating knowledge into solutions.”

Board member Stephen Willard explained last year the commission is motivated by the facts that it has been about 12 years since the NSF last formally assessed the criteria, there are “continuing discrepancies” in how the criteria are applied by applicants and reviewers, there are “internal and external reports of racial disparities in merit review,” and NSF can now “call on professional expertise regarding broader impacts that did not exist before.”

NSB Chair Dan Reed also stressed that the CHIPS and Science Act has set higher expectations for NSF to shepherd research into practical application, namely through the new Directorate for Technology, Innovation, and Partnerships.

The commission will consist of Willard and fellow board members Roger Beachy, Steven Leath, Julia Phillips, Scott Stanley, Keivan Stassun, Wanda Ward, and NSF staff members to be announced later.

More from FYI
FYI
/
Article
Senate appropriators propose modest budget increases for NSF and NASA science, in contrast to the House, ahead of the Dec. 11 funding deadline.
FYI
/
Article
NSF employees say their new headquarters is a major downgrade from their old building, with poor telecommunications connectivity and limited meeting spaces.
FYI
/
Article
Decisions on spending and White House control over science grants await a lame-duck Congress.
FYI
/
Article
Former NOAA officials say the dramatic changes increase the risk of data loss and will degrade the agency’s satellite capabilities.
/
Article
A traveling science demonstration can reach thousands of young students interested in STEM. Help inspire the next generation with these tips on creating your own science van.
/
Article
Writing is a classic choice for generating interest and engagement in STEM. You can wordsmith your way to a professional writing career with the following advice.
/
Article
High-speed videos reveal how a detached stinger uses a dual-piston mechanism to burrow into skin and pump a continuous flow of venom.
/
Article
Thoughtful collaborations can spark inspiration for both disciplines. If you want to conduct science outreach through the arts, this advice can help you get started.
/
Article
After a successful first road trip, antimatter could one day be delivered by vehicle to university labs.

Related Organizations